Fool's Gold

Synopsis
At the start of the episode, the Screaming Gophers enter the main lodge and immediately notice tension between the Killer Bass team and one of their members, Bridgette. Lindsay is forced by Heather to investigate the reason for this, and is informed by Harold that Bridgette and Tyler are in a secret relationship. This angers many Screaming Gophers, namely Heather, who side against Tyler for fraternizing with a member of the opposing team.

Chris then walks in and instructs each team to choose five players who will participate in the day's challenge. The Screaming Gophers select Geoff, Katie, Leshawna, Lindsay, and Trent, while the Killer Bass pick Bridgette, Courtney, Duncan, Harold, and Izzy. Chris explains the challenges shortly after; the selected campers will have to dive into the lake and retrieve a higher amount of fake gold pieces than their opponents in order to win.

Geoff, Lindsay, and Trent are the first campers to hop in, and retrieve no pieces of gold. Katie and Leshawna are unable to retrieve any, either, but are awarded for their valiant effort and strong teamwork. Next, Harold from the Killer Bass is pushed into the lake by Duncan and almost eaten alive by a shark; to make matters worse, he also comes out without any pieces of fake gold.

Finally, Bridgette, Courtney, Duncan, and Izzy dive in, and though a majority end up finding gold, Chris declares the challenge a tie and pits Bridgette and Tyler against each other in a tiebreaker game of underwater tug of war. Bridgette ends up winning and the Screaming Gophers are sentenced to the bonfire ceremony, where Heather convinces her alliance, consisting of Katie and Lindsay, to vote off Tyler. Both are placed in the bottom two, and after Tyler is eliminated, he criticizes Heather's sportsmanship and shares a kiss with Bridgette at the Dock of Shame, ending the episode.