Chris-napped

Synopsis
When the episode begins, Chef Hatchet informs the campers that their host, Chris, has been kidnapped and taken to Boney Island. He explains that Chris is trapped in the Cave of Treacherous Terror, then forces the teams to find their host by canoeing to the island and portaging their canoes across the island's forest. The campers make their way to the dock and assemble themselves into groups of twos and threes; each group takes a canoe and begins paddling away from Camp Wawanakwa.

While Harold sings throughout his canoe ride with Noah, Cody and Izzy discuss Duncan's possible relationship with Courtney. Meanwhile, Heather pressures Katie and Lindsay to paddle their group's canoe for her, and when Katie finally stands up to Heather by swearing at her, Heather convinces Lindsay to kick Katie off the canoe. Katie immediately quits Heather's alliance and hops off, joining Gwen, Leshawna, and Trent's canoe moments later.

Upon arriving to Boney Island, Harold insists that the Killer Bass turn left, but the team ends up going right. The Screaming Gophers arrive moments after their opponents and are attacked by Stymphalian geese, one of which picks up Heather and drops her into quicksand. Trent is horrified and asks her to take his hand as Gwen and Leshawna watch in amusement, and once she is saved, the Screaming Gophers decide to head in the left direction.

At the Cave of Treacherous Terror, the Killer Bass arrive and find Chris, who explains that the abduction was all part of an elaborate challenge that the Killer Bass have now won. Later, at the bonfire ceremony, Chris hands everyone on the Screaming Gophers a marshmallow except for Katie and Lindsay. A dramatic pause silences the campers, but Lindsay is eventually handed the final marshmallow, and Katie sadly takes the Dock of Shame after swearing at Heather one last time.